London
New York

Market Insights | Salary Transparency: Why Are We Still Keeping Pay a Secret?

19th November 2026

As the conversation around salary transparency gathers momentum, is it time for employers to rethink how they talk about pay?

Salary is one of the first things candidates consider when looking for a new role. It’s a perfectly reasonable question. After all, people need to know whether an opportunity makes financial sense before investing their time in exploring it.

Yet, despite how important salary is to almost everyone, it’s still surprisingly common to see job adverts that make no mention of it.

With the Government’s proposed Say What You Pay legislation bringing salary transparency back into the spotlight, it raises an interesting question: why are we still so reluctant to talk openly about pay?

The case for being upfront

From a recruitment perspective, there are some fairly obvious advantages to being transparent about salary from the outset.

For candidates, it removes the uncertainty. They can make an informed decision about whether a role is right for them, rather than going through several rounds of interviews only to discover that the salary doesn’t meet their expectations.

For employers, it can make the hiring process far more efficient.

There is sometimes a concern that publishing a salary range will simply attract more applications. But the real benefit isn’t necessarily attracting more people. It’s attracting the right people.

When candidates understand the salary, responsibilities and expectations from the beginning, they’re better placed to assess whether an opportunity is genuinely suitable.

And for recruiters, that means fewer mismatched expectations, more meaningful conversations and a better use of everyone’s time.

So why are employers hesitant?

Of course, there are reasons why some businesses prefer to keep salaries confidential.

Some want flexibility when negotiating with candidates. Others worry about creating tension internally, particularly if existing employees discover that new hires are being offered more for similar responsibilities.

And in certain cases, employers may simply not have settled on a precise salary because they’re open to hiring someone at different levels of experience.

These are understandable considerations, but they also highlight why salary transparency can be such a useful exercise.

If a business is uncomfortable publishing what it’s prepared to pay, it may be worth asking why.

Are salary structures consistent? Are existing employees being paid fairly? And are expectations for the role aligned with the budget?

Sometimes, the conversation around transparency reveals questions that are worth addressing regardless of what the legislation eventually requires.

It’s about more than money

Being transparent about salary doesn’t mean compensation becomes the only thing candidates care about.

In our conversations with candidates, flexibility, career progression, leadership exposure, learning opportunities and company culture all continue to play an important part in career decisions.

The strongest opportunities offer a compelling overall package, rather than relying solely on remuneration.

But salary is still a fundamental part of that conversation.

And being open about it can create a stronger foundation of trust between an employer and a prospective employee.

Candidates increasingly value honesty throughout the recruitment process. A clear salary range is one relatively simple way for employers to demonstrate that transparency from the very beginning.

A wider conversation about fairness

There’s also a broader issue here.

When salaries aren’t disclosed, candidates may enter negotiations with very different levels of information. Some will feel confident asking for more, while others may be less comfortable negotiating or may not know what the market is paying.

Greater transparency has the potential to make these conversations more consistent and help reduce unexplained pay disparities.

It won’t solve every issue around pay fairness, of course. But it can encourage employers to think more carefully about how salaries are determined, communicated and reviewed.

And that can only be a positive direction for the wider employment market.

Don’t wait for legislation to start the conversation

Whether or not the proposed rules are introduced in their current form, salary transparency is already becoming an increasingly important part of the recruitment conversation.

For employers, this is an opportunity to review salary structures, understand where they sit in the market and consider how openly they communicate pay.

For candidates, it’s about having the information they need to make informed career decisions.

At Biscuit, we’ve always believed that the best recruitment relationships are built on openness, honesty and a clear understanding of expectations on both sides.

Salary is an important part of that.

And perhaps the question shouldn’t be whether employers have to disclose salaries, but why so many are still choosing not to.

Interested in understanding how your salaries compare? Request a complimentary copy of our 2027 London Salary & Market Insights report.

copyright © biscuit recruitment. All rights reserved.